Monday, December 2, 2013

Essay #2 Literary Analysis Paper "Paternal Love in William Butler Yeats "A Prayer for my Daughter""

Irina Arias
Ms. Matyakubova
English 110, section D
6 October 2013
Literary Analysis Paper Draft
Paternal Love in William Butler Yeats’ “A Prayer for my Daughter”
A parent’s love for their child is beyond measure. From the moment of conception, they spend countless hours wondering about their lives, personalities and how these aspects would affect their lives outside of the protective confines of childhood and adolescence in the real world. The anxious fear that all parents have for their children in the future is what Yeats expresses in his poem “A prayer for my Daughter” as well as the criticisms of society at large. In this poem the reader can detect the paternal care that Yeats expresses for his daughter and his protective feelings for her. This can also be seen through the way Yeats’ uses imagery, tone and point of view to express his feelings of apprehension over his daughter’s life as an adult, her growth and development and his hope that she avoids making the same mistakes that Yeats and other people have committed in the past.
The poem begins in the first stanza of Yeats’ description of their environment. He briefly describes the “storm” (Yeats 1) that is howling outside and his daughter’s relatively comfortable place under the sheets of her crib in her room. He also elaborates on the relative comfort of her daughter’s room as opposed to the “roof leveling wind…sea wind scream” that is outside their house. (Yeats 5, 11) He paints a picture of the sea wind that blows around the house as an ominous and destructive force that seems to be an ever looming threat for both the father and daughter and that may represent social or political turmoil. The imagery used throughout the story evokes a sense of pessimism in the outside world or society and a great fear for his daughter one day being in the storm known as the real world. In the stanzas to come he then expresses his desires for his daughter’s social and ethical growth as she enters the world outside of the paternal care and protection he gives her, becoming more and more optimistic about how she may be.
In the third stanza he begins to elaborate on the virtue of beauty and its dangers. He goes on to state that he hopes her to become beautiful, but not to the extent that it would be “consider[ed] … sufficient end” (Yeats 23) and become vain and proud because of it. He then describes what happens once beauty comes in the way of intelligence and a good heart, and how it leads to the loss of the ability to choose people based on their personalities and the inability to make true friends. In his opinion, the use of beauty and vanity to measure the worth of others is a mark of someone who is not educated, cultured and respectable; and those virtues are the ones that he envisions for his daughter in the future. He also feels that because of this, any deviation or change in his daughter’s behavior in the future from what he envisions her to have is a mark of failure and ineptitude as a father trying to raise a child with good morals and ethics.  He advises his daughter against possessing these qualities and interacting with people that have them because of the effects that these virtues have had on people that he had known in his past. To emphasize his point on the benefits of having proper morals and ethics in order to make good life choices, he describes the life of Helen.
In the next stanza, he describes the life of Helen, a Greek goddess who, without the paternal advice of her father, “could have her way” (Yeats 31) and choose any man that she had wanted for herself, but without the approval of her father came the lack of guidance and proper advice needed to help someone pick a proper partner. And so, Helen eventually finds a partner that is inferior to her position. From this he expresses the idea that to be able to make the best choice for a partner and for their future, the advice of the father is needed. Tsung – Chi Chang expresses a similar agreement with this idea as well as his sentiments on beauty and success by saying that “For Yeats, a woman blessed with mere prettiness is not necessarily endowed with completeness and happiness…[Yeats] proposes that  are far from his standard of [an] ideal wom[a]n because [of their lack of success] in securing partners with fit qualifications” (Chang) it is from this that he sees intelligence above beauty and  urges his daughter to see past society’s superficial values of beauty as  success and focus on intelligence and proper social values. It is from his regard of women in this specific stanza we could argue that Yeats expresses some bewilderment and a lack of knowledge about women. He describes them as people who “eat a crazy salad with their meat” (Yeats 34) and do things that he struggles to understand. Within the point of view as a father and as a man, he views women as more confusing and unpredictable however because of the love that he has for his daughter and in an effort to help guide and advise her, he tries to understand and translate the actions of women.  Therefore the advice that he gives to his daughter is with actions and behaviors that he could understand (in terms of gender roles in that time period). Many of the behaviors that he envisions for her are modesty, kindness and understanding as well as many others throughout the poem.
In the next stanza, the father sees modesty, courtesy and respect as aspects of a woman that he feels that his daughter should have. He emphasizes the fact that beauty, though alluring to both genders, is often a deterrent in earning the hearts of others “that are not entirely beautiful” (Yeats 39). As he frequently does, he emphasizes this through the generalizations of the pitfalls and the fates of other people as they allow themselves to be “made wise” (Yeats 41) by love, become tricked and left heartbroken. It is throughout the entire poem that we see his evident disdain of the deceit and trickery of women onto unsuspecting men, noting is as an ethical and social error, he makes it an important aspect that he feels that his daughter should know about and avoid. Instead of cunning and deceit, he sees the value in intelligence and maturity. He feels that he proper values are silent modesty and decorum as well as the avoidance of gossip and quarreling, especially in public. As a father he values the maintenance of proper behavior and the avoidance of bad habits that could make a person’s life more difficult. He then goes on to state the effects his bad habits and mistakes have cost him.
Yeats describes the desolate and “dried up” (Yeats 57) condition of his mind, which, after years of bad habits and mistakes have had a toll on his creativity, optimism and view of others. He describes hate as the single most effective deterrent of creativity and happiness and describes a mind without one as able to maintain the decorum and inner mental peace that all people should have. It is from his descriptions of his mental state and the close, accurate descriptions of women, whose minds had changed under the heat and pressure of hatred, is when we see how much Yeats has learned from his mistakes as well as the extent that he doesn’t want her to go down the same road that he has. He doesn’t want her to become as emotionally bankrupt as he has because of the expense of his emotions and effort through anger. Hatred, to Yeats infects the mind and drives the most intellectual of women to become undesirable and lose their emotions and respect, he also emphasizes the taxing effects intellectual hatred has on people and the way that it affects others. Hatred is the worst of all the negative virtues in the sense that it takes the thoughts and emotions of the people who are feeling hate. Finally, the cautionary and foreboding tone begins to change as the effects of anger and hatred begin to fade away, and the person who was angry begins to “recover radical innocence” (Yeats 74) and realize the brighter sides of life and remember that through the trial and tribulations that could, and make, some people angry, is that people should always try to smile and be more positive. Overall, he tells his daughter to smile and take on life with a positive attitude, to learn from his mistakes and pitfalls as a father and not to fall into the fiery, contagious hatred that could transform people into undesirables.
Yeats then sees into the future, envisioning his daughter’s life as she listens to all of his advice and lives happily with her husband. The home that Yeats envisions for his daughter is one of security and safety within traditions and convention. We can infer from the storm outside the house and his insistence on the maintenance of culture and refinement that there is some kind of social unrest or change going on that has the father nervous about the status of women in society and how it may affect his daughter’s growth and development in the future. Through his visions of his daughter in the future he envisions the stability and proper social norms that he believes women in society should have.
Yeats, throughout the story expresses a warning but reproachful nature of all the dangers that are out there for his daughter to fall victim to. He expresses his need to protect his daughter through the safe boundaries of cultural and social rules. Desmond Pacey expresses this sentiment by saying in “Yeats, in his emphasis upon order, discipline and self-restraint [sees the child] as a delicate growth which needs the shelter of social and civilized values [and] as a … blossom which society will warp and wither.” (Pacey ) he feels that the best chance that she has for survival is to have the protective ‘blanket’ of societal rules and customs that would help her avoid bad habits and behavior. Through his emphasis on being herself and avoiding peer pressure, we see that in Yeats point of view, he sees the low ethical state of women in his time a and fears for his daughter’s influence by women that could negatively corrupt her. In order to reassure himself and find a way to help her, he describes his feelings in writing. This poem is proof of a father’s love for his child as well as the mentality of a worried and caring parent.
Works Cited
"A Prayer For My Daughter." Poets.org - Poetry, Poems, Bios & More. Academy of American                   Poets., n.d. Web. 9 Oct. 2013.
Chang, Tsung – Chi. “W.B. Yeats, Cultural Nationalism, and Disempowered Women” Tamkang          Review43.1 (2012): 51+. Literature Resource Center. Web. 7 October 2013
Pacey, Desmond. “Children in the Poetry of Yeats” The Dallhouse Review” 50.2 (summer 1970): 233-248. Rpt in Poetry Criticism. Ed. Carol T Gaffke. Vol 20. Detroit: Gale Research, 1998. Literature Resource Center. Web 7 October 2013.


No comments:

Post a Comment