Irina Arias
October 24 2013
Ms. Matyakubova
English 110 section D
Argumentative Paper First Draft #2
The Struggles of
Immigrant Children in the 21st Century
Immigration,
in a dictionary sense, is defined as the act or actions of moving permanently
from one country to another. While this helps to define what it is, immigration
has many more aspects to it, such as the reasons why people emigrate from their
countries and what effect this may have on the people in the emigrated
countries and immigrated countries. People leave for many reasons, such as
racism (avoiding a certain group of people), war (including social and
political unrest) and simply to live a better life. In the many years of human
civilization, people have moved around and settled for different reasons; such
as religious, economic, and social reasons. Many of these immigrants moved as
families and worked hard to maintain their cultures and ways of life, they have
also tried to maintain peace and relative happiness in their new homes in the
face of groups that may not be as welcoming to the newest wave of immigrants.
But a facet of immigration that is often overlooked or marginalized is the
aspect of it that affects children and the family as a unit. For them it may be
more difficult to assimilate or make friendships in their lifetime, and they
may also face complications and struggle in finding jobs and having equal
rights. Immigration in the 21st century negatively affects the families,
children and future relationships between parents and children through feelings
of discrimination, inequality and disconnection.
Modern
– day immigration is caused mostly by social and political unrest and the
pursuit of a home that provides opportunities for growth and education. In the
examples used in this paper, three specific cases of immigration in certain
countries are explained and analyzed. First is the immigration of various
minority groups to the United States for religious and political reasons. Many
of these immigrants come from countries such as Mexico and other South American
countries as well as the Middle East. Another is the immigration of Jewish
people to Israel and the final is the immigration of people to Germany from the
regions around the area. In these three cases the activities of the children
and families are expressed and are compared to see whether immigration plays a
large part in the children’s and families’ development. The process and aftermath
of immigration affects immigrants in three main ways: economically, legally and
sociologically.
Immigration
affects the families of immigrants economically in many ways. For people that
move to other countries, it’s common for them to struggle economically and not
have the same type of jobs and lifestyles that they used to have in their
previous homes. One example of this occurring is the immigration of Jews to
Israel. Throughout the years Jews have come to Israel coming for a better life
and for the greater opportunities present there. Many of these immigrants also
come from places of “culture
and science” (Dwairy et al.) and have degrees and high paying jobs,
however, their condition in Israel is completely different. Many of these immigrants can’t find jobs that pay similar
amounts than what they had back home and others end up settling for lower
income jobs and so into a lower socioeconomic status, which puts a strain on to
the family. Less money coming into the household would mean that children would
have to work and would face more pressure in supporting the family. With these
financial problems, it becomes difficult for parents to “be involved in their
children’s learning process and functioning” (Dwairy et al.) and so
would lead displays of antisocial behavior and an inability to bond with
others. The economic changes and subsequent changes in socioeconomic status
leads to stress in adolescents and would also lead to a higher possibility of
lower grades in school, poorer health and poor mental health because of the lower
chances for any economic change; in some countries, economic worries also
accompany worries over legal troubles and the family’s status in living in that
country.
Legal
responses to immigration have also negatively affected immigrants and their
families, with children affected the most. In many cases countries such as in
the United States have passed laws relating to immigration that restricts the
rights and abilities of immigrants that don’t have citizenship. Laws such as
the 1990 Immigration act, which limits the number of immigrants coming to the
united states and the Illegal Immigrant Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act,
which states that immigrants present in the US for more than 180 but less than
360 days must remain out of the US for 3 years before obtaining a pardon and
applying for a green card. Because of these actions, the lives and safety of
immigrant families are at a constant risk of deportation and separation. In
recent years, there have been cases of deportation and separation of immigrant
families occurring, leaving the children of immigrant parents with family
members or in the foster care system. Because of these risks, the chance that a
family may be broken up and separated for many years at a time lead to
emotional and economic distress. For children of immigrants without a green
card or citizenship, there are less available opportunities for scholarships,
financial aid and other monetary or merit based rewards. Because of these
factors immigrant children also have fewer rates of attending college and
having better lives. Because of the situation presented to these children, they
grow up in an environment where they “confront a series of barriers that prohibit them from
moving forward in tandem with their documented peers. [therefore research]
show[s] that these experiences are linked with leveled motivation and feelings
of anger and hopelessness” (Gonzales et al.). from the constant
obstacles that immigrants face on the state and national levels many
undocumented immigrants tend to stay in their socioeconomic groups and have
fewer chances of ever getting an education and better jobs. These legal
constraints to the children of immigrants lead to emotional and psychological
affects in their future.
The economic and legal
effects of immigration vary by country, but in most cases these effects also
lead to severe stress and more difficult transitions into the culture and
society of their new home. In most of these countries, the effects have led to
severe emotional stress. In the United States, in an American Behavioral Scientist
Article, they elaborate on “a link between these stressful circumstances and reported anxiety
over obtaining jobs and financing higher education as well as constant fears of
deportations. Many also speak of deep feelings of shame about their
undocumented status.” (Gonzales et al. 2013) The stigma of being
undocumented and being unable to attain the basic things that their legal
contemporaries obtain also lead to a “secondary boarder [that] reinforce[es] legal
exclusions.” (Gonzales et al.) This in effect leads to higher rates of
mental health illnesses and poor health because of stress. These effects are more evident in children, adolescent and
teenage immigrants. In the United States there is also a “political backlash”
(Gonzales et al.) against immigrants and a general sense of prejudice against
them. Socially this places pressure on undocumented immigrant children because
of their lack of legal aid and financial dependence on the family’s income. For
many countries, and especially in the United States, the assimilation of
immigrant families and children is oftentimes unreceptive and unsympathetic to
immigrants.
However,
a counter argument could be made from a few cases in which adolescent
assimilation in a foreign country was quick and has very few struggles in terms
of personal relationships and other factors. One example of this is the arrival
and settling of ethnic immigrants of German descent who had previously lived in
countries in the former Soviet Union and other satellite countries. The
relative ease at which these immigrants and natives had assimilated and
cohabitated peacefully, especially in adolescents and children, was described
as having friendship homophily; which is “the principle that contact between similar people
occurs at a higher rate than at a higher rate than dissimilar people” (McPherson,
et.al,…) In these cases presented by the center for applied developmental
science at the Frederick – Schiller University, the families and children of
immigrants have had less or minimal social or political problems as they
emigrated to Germany and its surrounding areas because of the similarities in
heritage and ancestry. In this situation, the immigrants of German descent
receive “instant
citizenship and financial support…[but adolescents still experienced] similar
cases of difficulties in language acquisition and social integration.”
(Titzman, et al.) People in these areas receiving immigrants have been told of
their arrival and have been educated about them. From this example we could
also see that the discrimination faced by other immigrant groups in other
countries come from lack of knowledge and prejudice towards an unknown group of
people, and so this fosters racism and xenophobia from the native people that
live there. It is from the relative understanding between the German natives
and immigrants of German descent that their assimilation and settlement had
been a relatively peaceful one.
Immigration
is a major change that an adolescent may go through in their lives.
Unfortunately for many adolescents all over the world today, this is a reality
many of them face because of social and political unrest, wars, and the lack of
benefits and opportunities where they live. While in some cases many immigrants
can have tranquil and seamless assimilation into a new community and culture,
most of these immigrant groups and communities face economic hardship,
prejudice and xenophobia that could cause immigrant children to have a hard
time adjusting and fitting in with other people.
No comments:
Post a Comment