Irina
Arias
5
November 2013
Ms.
Matyakubova
English
110 Section D
Journal
#9
Debates about immigration
In the articles, “illegal
immigration doesn’t not threaten America” by Richard Taylor and “America must
take stronger measures to halt illegal immigration” by Michael Scott, two
vastly different and opposite opinions about immigration in the united states,
people’s opinions regarding it and the necessary actions that should be enacted
to deal with and respond to immigration to the United States.
In the first article, the author, an
immigrant himself, describes his story of immigration and the impact that it
has had on his life and his view of other people. He then describes the term
“American” (Rayner) and the connotation and meanings that it should have with
the onset of immigration in the United States. Describing how people’s feelings
about immigration quickly erode fast into a sensitive race debate show how Americas’
feelings about immigration and of immigrants reflect on feelings about themselves
and their identities. He sees the evident irony present in the animosity and
xenophobia that an “immigrant nation” (Rayner) has on immigrants. From this
article I feel that the author not only investigated the truth behind the
numbers and their meaning, but the ideals and statements, and what their truth
was as well. He really made me think about the reasons that people feel the way
that they do about immigration and the effect that it has on people’s feelings
and perception of America. One of the most poignant sentiments that he had
evoked from his article was the feelings of anxiety confusion and subliminal
xenophobia that people could have towards anyone that they weren’t familiar
with, and in this case it was the reactions of Californians towards immigrants
as they passed the proposition 187 in 1996. From this I understand that
people’s fears for themselves as well as their fears for other people and
change in general can manifest in many different sentiments and expressions.
The second article conveys the exactly
different sentiments. The author feels tae governments aren’t steeping in and enforcing
boarder control, deportations and restriction of rights to immigrants. While
this article made many arguments as to why immigration hurts more than helps, expresses
factual inaccuracies and misinformed ideas as to what illegal immigrants do in
the United States. I feel that the author doesn’t understand the aspects of
immigration that bring people to the United States and so fails to properly
justify his arguments.
From the analysis of these two articles I have come to the
conclusion that immigration in the United States has not affected or acted as a
detriment to the economy or livelihood of the United States in any way. In
terms of economic development from the incoming illegal immigrants, there has
been a resurgence of economic prosperity and economic development as well as
more consumers and workers. Because more money is in circulation, there is more
growth to the economy.
No comments:
Post a Comment