Irina
Arias
Ms.
Matyakubova
22
September 2013
Journal
#6 Only daughter by Sandra Cisneros
When
Sandra writes that ‘I am a daughter and only a daughter’ she means to highlight
the main point of the essay as well as the main points of her essay and her
main point of contention with her family and her culture. In her family and her
culture, the fact that she is born a girl makes her both socially repulsive
(her brothers did not want to be seen playing with a girl because they saw it
as beneath them) and of lover expectations 0fr her future and role in her
family ( her father only agrees to send her to college because he expected her
to marry an educated and financially successful man and have children) and so
this places her in a situation that enables her to not only defy the cultural expectations
that her family has for her, but to prove to her family that there is more to
her than childbearing and marriage.
She
also frequently states throughout the story that because she is the only
daughter she is frequently overlooked in various ways. In conversations, Sandra’s
father usually speaks about his children using the word hijos, which in Spanish grammar is the male pronoun used to address
a group of children. This accidental formality of the Spanish language is seen
as just that, an accidental formality (it is actually a rule in Spanish grammar
to use the male pronoun for boys when addressing a group of children as long as
there is a boy in the Group) and despite her reassurances to the audience that
his formality was not meant to insult or degrade her, the use of the pronoun
reinforces not only her feelings of being disregarded, but the cultural
overlooking of women in general. These events cause her to be lonely and also
lead to her eventual introspective thought that uses today as a writer.
Cisneros
writes for her father because she wants to prove to him that she is worth more than
her cultural expectations and her gender. She recounts several times her desire
in having her father have more than a passing inquiry of what she was writing
and wanting him to ask about the content
of her writing and having a dialogue with her about her work. As she attains success
outside of home in the literary world, she seeks the validation of her talents
from her father. Because in the Hispanic culture the opinion of the father is
usually the most important and also because of her love and respect for him,
she seeks his validation the most. The reason why she says that the reaction
her father had was the “most wonderful thing that has happened to her last year”
(Cisneros) was because of the positive reaction that her father had to her
writing and the resultant feelings of pride, validation and acceptance that she
had been looking for throughout her entire life, and therefore led to the
resolution to the problem throughtout the entire story.
No comments:
Post a Comment